The real value of patient choice in the NHS

Patient choice has been part of the NHS in England for manore than two decades, giving people greater control and helping them access treatment sooner. The Independent Healthcare Providers Network explains why choice still matters.
IHPN

Patient choice has been a feature of the NHS in England for the last two decades and has been supported by successive governments as a way of giving people more control over their care and helping them access treatment sooner.

Choice can take different forms, from choosing a GP to using a personal health budget. But the right to choose where you receive NHS treatment was formally introduced in the early 2000s, in part as a way to help reduce waiting lists.

Giving patients a choice of hospitals and clinics, including independent providers delivering NHS-funded care, can help make better use of available capacity across the system. It also creates an incentive for providers to respond to what matters to patients, including where and how quickly they can access care.

For patients who cannot afford to pay privately, that choice can be particularly important. It gives them more control over where they’re treated without changing who funds their care.

Patient choice can make a significant difference to waiting times

More than two decades after patient choice was introduced, the difference it can make is clear.

Research carried out over the years by the Independent Healthcare Providers Network (IHPN), using NHS performance data, found that patients in England need to travel an average of just 13 miles — around 30 minutes by car — to an alternative provider to reduce their wait for NHS treatment by 8.5 weeks.

The variation becomes even clearer when looking at individual specialties and regions. For ear, nose and throat treatment in the East of England, patients waiting with providers in the bottom third for performance wait almost 20 weeks on average. Those with providers in the top third wait just over seven weeks; a difference of around 13 weeks.

For gynaecology in the Southeast, average waits are around 19 weeks among providers in the bottom third, compared with just over seven weeks among those in the top third.

And for orthopaedic treatment in the South West, patients with providers in the bottom third wait around 18 weeks, compared with eight weeks in the top third.

These differences show the practical impact that exercising choice can have. For some patients, selecting a different provider could mean receiving treatment weeks or even months sooner.

Choice can also help make better use of NHS capacity

The longer-term case for patient choice goes beyond individual waiting times.

A system where patients are properly supported to understand their options can help distribute demand more effectively between providers. Where one service has a long wait and another has available capacity, giving patients the information and ability to choose between them can help reduce those imbalances.

That matters for patients, but it also matters for the way NHS resources are used. Better use of existing capacity can support more equal access to care and reduce the pressure created when demand becomes concentrated in particular services or locations.

Many patients still don’t know what choices they have

The challenge is that having a right to choose doesn’t necessarily mean patients know about it or feel able to use it. Despite longstanding commitments to patient choice, there are still significant gaps in public awareness.

NHS estimates suggest that fewer than one in four people report being offered a choice of provider when referred by their GP for treatment. IHPN research has also found that four in ten people are unaware of their legal right to choose a hospital or clinic for a first NHS outpatient appointment.

More recent polling commissioned by IHPN and conducted by Savanta found that fewer than half of people (49%) know which healthcare providers have the shortest or longest waiting times in their local area.

That leaves many patients without the information they need to make an informed decision, even when choosing a different provider could substantially reduce their wait.

Making patient choice work better

At a time when the NHS is trying to reduce waiting lists, make better use of available capacity and give patients greater control over their care, patient choice should play an important role.

Making that choice meaningful requires more than the legal right itself. Patients and GPs need clearer information about the options available, including waiting times, and referral processes need to make those choices straightforward to use.

If patients are better supported to understand and exercise their rights, choice has the potential to improve access to care, give people greater control over their treatment and help existing NHS capacity be used more effectively.

‍

About Cara

Cara McDonagh is the Director of Communications at The Independent Healthcare Providers Network (IHPN).  

IHPN is the membership organisation for independent healthcare providers across the UK. Its 120+ members deliver a wide range of services to NHS and private patients, spanning primary, community, diagnostic, hospital, mental health and neurodevelopmental care. IHPN brings providers together, represents the sector and works with government, the NHS and other partners to support high-quality patient care and help independent providers make a positive contribution to UK healthcare.

‍

Featured

The real value of patient choice in the NHS
The real value of patient choice in the NHS
No items found.
Ready to join thousands that already trust Semble?
4.5 Capterra
4.3 Google