Being clinically good at what you do is the foundation for becoming a Right to Choose provider, but that alone doesn’t show that your organisation is ready for a contract. Commissioners need evidence that your governance, clinical pathways and operations meet NHS standards.
Right to Choose gives patients in England a legal right to select where they’re treated when their GP refers them, including for many mental health and neurodevelopmental services such as ADHD and autism assessments. The choice can include independent providers as well as NHS services, with the NHS still funding the patient’s care. To accept those referrals, an independent provider needs an NHS Standard Contract with an integrated care board (ICB), the NHS organisation that plans and buys health services for its area. The ICB has to be satisfied that you can deliver safely within NHS rules before it offers one.
At Lighthouse Pathways, which provides private ADHD and autism assessments, we treated readiness as an evidence exercise from the start. Here’s what that involved, and what I’d organise earlier if I did it again.
What evidence do commissioners want to see from healthcare providers who are getting ready for Right to Choose?
Commissioners want proof that you already deliver the service well and that you can do it within the NHS system. Showing what you do now carries more weight than describing what you intend to do.
The evidence we pulled together fell into three categories:
- Regulation and workforce: registration with the Care Quality Commission (CQC), professional registrations, staff credentials and safeguarding arrangements.
- Clinical delivery: clinical policies and standard operating procedures (SOPs), examples of pathways already delivered privately, prescribing and medicines management processes, assessment templates and anonymised sample reports.
- Governance: clinical governance structure, outcome measures, audit arrangements, complaints handling, information governance controls and escalation pathways.
As well as evidence of your own standards, ICBs need assurance that you can meet NHS requirements consistently. That includes the terms of the NHS Standard Contract, data reporting, referral management, patient choice, clinical correspondence, incident reporting and the capacity to manage NHS volumes safely.
Requirements vary between ICBs, so treat this as a starting point and check the documents for any opportunity you apply for.
Governance has to be visible in everyday delivery
Commissioners look for governance they can see in how the service actually runs. A well-written policy helps, but they also want to know who owns it, how staff are trained in it, how compliance is monitored and what happens when something goes wrong.
For us, the biggest challenge was making those connections for every policy. In our experience, it’s also where commissioners look most closely. Writing the policies themselves was reasonably straightforward.
A useful check for any policy is to ask who owns it, how staff learn it, how you know it’s being followed and what happens when it isn’t followed. Each answer should be backed by something you could show a commissioner, such as a training record or an audit result.
Your CQC registration needs to fit the opportunity
The scope and location of your CQC registration can matter more than you’d expect. Some opportunities require a CQC-registered location in the ICB’s own region, and that’s not something you can put in place quickly once a notice has been published. One opportunity we were pursuing had this requirement, and it wasn’t enough for us just to say we would set up a registered location in the area.
Contractual arrangements can differ between ICBs too. When you read an opportunity’s requirements, check that your registration covers the services, age groups and locations it asks for.
How do you show a pathway is NICE-aligned?
You show alignment with the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) by making it traceable. A commissioner should be able to follow each stage of your pathway from written procedure to clinical template, patient record, report and governance audit.
NICE guidance sets out how conditions such as ADHD and autism should be recognised, assessed and managed. We mapped each stage of our patient pathway against the relevant NICE recommendations, then made sure there was operational evidence behind each one. That covered:
- Before assessment: referral and triage, information gathering, developmental history and clinical history.
- Assessment and diagnosis: validated assessment tools, differential diagnosis, physical health considerations, risk and safeguarding, diagnostic decision-making and report production.
- After diagnosis: treatment discussions, starting medication and ongoing monitoring.
The key principle for us was never treating a questionnaire score as a diagnosis. Our pathways require appropriately qualified clinicians to weigh evidence from several sources, including how far someone’s difficulties affect them across different settings, any co-occurring conditions and alternative explanations.
To show the pathway working, we set up a test patient in our patient record system and used this to demonstrate the whole flow, alongside the templates and anonymised letters we use day to day.
Make sure your evidence covers the full Right to Choose pathway your contract would include. Demonstrating that you can assess doesn’t show that you can safely manage medication, monitoring, onward referral, shared care with GPs and discharge. Some contracts are for assessment only, but most of the ones we’ve come across cover the whole pathway, from assessment through medication and titration to aftercare.
What should you get organised before you apply for Right to Choose as a healthcare provider?
There’s a lot to prepare, but much of the evidence should come from how you already deliver care. Most of the effort is in assembling it and showing how each document is used in practice. If I were starting again, I’d do four things earlier:
- Build one evidence library. Keep all your readiness evidence in a single place from the outset, with a named owner and a review date for every document.
- Map it against what you’ll be asked. Check the library against CQC requirements, the NHS Standard Contract, NICE guidance, information governance rules and the questions likely to come up in provider accreditation applications, such as workforce competence and pathway scope.
- Set up reporting before you need it. Start tracking capacity, waiting times, outcomes, complaints, incidents, safeguarding, workforce resilience and performance against service standards. ICBs want to see this alongside clinical delivery. It’s much easier to embed early than to add later.
- Check eligibility before you commit. Make this the first thing you do with any new opportunity. Some requirements, such as a registered location in the area, can’t be met quickly, and it’s better to find that out before investing heavily in an application.
You won’t need to start from scratch for each new ICB you apply to. In our experience, a lot of the application pack can be reused, with some adjustments for local requirements. If you keep your evidence library up to date, each subsequent application will be a more manageable piece of work.
